Judgment Day

[Love Amore]

http://longislandbankruptcyblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/06/judgesfinal_article.jpg

ARE YOU READY FOR YOUR JUDGMENT?


No, really, are you ready for your latest finished battle to be judged? Cause if you are, then you're in the right place!

The steps are quite simple; first you agree to a battle, then you come here and fill out the form at the bottom of this post and post it, then judges will be assigned to your battle and they'll judge it AS you fight! Super simple for all involved!


Well you can!
Or, at least you can try out to judge. All you have to do is fill out the application below and PM it to me! I'll look it over and if we need a new judge you'll be accepted right away, if we're good on judges at the moment I'll let you know and then get back to you when we need you!

Username:
Age:
Reasons for wanting to judge:
Judging format (Will you use the format I use, or make your own? If you make your own, what will it look like?):

Remember; PM this to me, don't post it.



Judges Roster:
SQJPure
Doughguy
Bee Bear
Arail

Note; judges now work in PAIRS so if you request a judge please request a PAIR of judges.



Judgement Request Form: (One per battle, please.)

Battle Arena (link):
Combatants:
Writers:
Post number of first post:
Type of battle:
Requested judge pair:

The post numbers are to be found in the upper right corners of each post. Good luck!

[Cfavano]

Battle Arena (link): http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=38783&page=2
Combatants: Haytham Kenway vs. Captain Barbossa
Writers: Cfavano vs. DaGeekyGamer
Post number of first post: 12
Post number of last post:31
Type of battle: Single
Requested judge (optional, include a reason): Love Amore, cause you're the main judge

[Love Amore]

Not quite sure your done there, 15 posts a piece so that means 30 total.

[Cfavano]

OH. I just thought 15 posts.

[Love Amore]

Easy mistake, no worries.

BATTLE ON!

[Cfavano]

well, I think I won anyway, but it's best not to prejudge or assume.

[Zatory-Master]

Battle Arena (link): http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=38394&page=4
Combatants: Shizuo and Quelaag
Writers: Zatory-Master and DoughGuy
Post number of first post: 33
Post number of last post: 63
Type of battle: Single

[Love Amore]

I'll get it done tonight or tomorrow morning!

[Zatory-Master]

Thank you!

[SQJ]

In Breaking News:


http://i590.photobucket.com/albums/ss341/SQJPure/largeAnimePaperscans_Street-Figh-1-1.gif


I'm adding the members of the council to the Judging List, that Includes Jacagos,, Kiwi and Myself. We will be adding up our own judging abilities, fortunately as being the founding members of SMUT we know more about the rules and the flow of Power Vs Skill in battles than any one else. So there's no training required(Which makes us meaner Judges Bwhahaha).

Note: We are not Judge replacements. We are Judge support. As a battles have a knack of ending at the same time we will be available to be asked for and Love Amore can call us if she is busy.

You can request us but we have the right to transfer their judging duties if they feel that they are regular judges available.

[Craze]

EDIT; nevurrrmind, the battle wasn't over yet x3

[Cfavano]

Battle Arena (link): http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=38897
Combatants: The God Emperor of Humanity, Nightmare Moon
Writers: Cfavano, Eddren
Post number of first post: 2
Post number of last post: 31
Type of battle: single

[SQJ]

Battle Arena (link): http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=38897
Combatants: The God Emperor of Humanity, Nightmare Moon
Writers: Cfavano, Eddren
Post number of first post: 2
Post number of last post: 31
Type of battle: single

The pure one is on it!

[SQJ]

Looks like everything has bee judged accept my battle with Geeky.

[SQJ]

Future judging list, if there's something you like to ask me please fee free to ask.





DoughGuy & Bee

to Judge
Pure & Geeky


Pure & Kiwi


DoughGuy & Bee



DoughGuy & Kiwi


Bee & Pure



Love Amore & Kiwi


Spazz & Geeky



Love Amore & Bee


Kiwi & DoughGuy



Love Amore & Pure


Kiwi & Zatory



Love & Kiwi


Jeremy & Dough

[DoughGuy]

Battle Arena:http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=38438
Combatants: Dart Feld and Shunsui
Writers: DoughGuy and Jeremor
Post number of first post: 2
Post number of last post: 31
Type of battle: Single
Requested judge: Love and Kiwi (cause Pure said so)

[Bee Bear]

Battle Arena: http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=38425
Combatants: Ahriman and Ulquiorra
Writers: DoughGuy and Bee Bear
Post number of first post: #23
Post number of last post: #54
Type of battle: Single
Requested judge: Pure and Kiwi

[Love Amore]

Some changes HAVE been made to the request system, the changes are minor but please check it out before requesting a judgment.

[Jacogos]

Battle Arena (link): My place (http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=35677).
Combatants: Richard vs. the God-Emperor of Mankind
Writers: Jacogos vs. Cfavano
Post number of first post: #2
Type of battle: Single - 30 posts
Requested judge pair: Doesn't matter a lick to me.

[DoughGuy]

Battle Arena (link): http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=38783&page=6&p=1285904&viewfull=1#post1285904
Combatants: Quelaag vs Xigbar
Writers: DoughGuy vs Craze
Post number of first post: 58
Type of battle: Single
Requested judge pair: Bee and Pure

[Bee Bear]

Battle Arena: http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=38425
Combatants: Fereydoon vs Seras Victoria
Writers: Danijel vs Bee Bear
Post number of first post: #2
Type of battle: Single
Requested judge pair: Pure and Arial

[Tolvo]

Battle Arena (link):http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=40058
Combatants: Mike Dawson versus Hidan
Writers: Tolvo versus Cfavano
Post number of first post: 2
Type of battle: Single
Requested judge pair: Doughguy and Bee

[CrumpetCannon]

Here we are


Battle Arena (link): http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=40251
Combatants: Ezio Auditore Da Firenze vs Iorek Byrnison
Writers: Lukasade vs CrunpetCannon
Post number of first post: #2
Type of battle: Single
Requested judge pair: SQJPure and Arail

Our first ever RP (so proud)
Many thanks to SQJPure for letting me know just how to get it judged!

[Death of Korzan]

Battle Arena (link): http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=35424&page=1
Combatants: Sips vs. Albus Dumbledore
Writers: Death of Korzan and SQJPure
Post number of first post: #93
Type of battle: Single
Requested judge pair: Anyone, but preferably someone who knows both characters.

[Lukasade]

Battle Arena (link): http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=40251&page=4
Combatants: Sam Gideon, Raiden
Writers: Lukasade, Fergy
Post number of first post: #36
Type of battle: Single
Requested judge pair: I don't mind :)

[Momo]

Battle Arena (link):http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=40329
Combatants: Octodad vs Helena
Writers: Momo, RossSandwich
Post number of first post: #2
Type of battle: Single
Requested judge pair: i don't really mind. It would be pretty helpful if you could give me pointers in how i can improve my writing.

[Jacogos]

Battle Arena (link): CF's Mount Bervenia (http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=38897&page=6&p=1303480&viewfull=1#post1303480)
Combatants: Richard vs. Juliet
Writers: Jacogos vs. Cfavano
Post number of first post: 51
Type of battle: Single
Requested judge pair: Pure and Dough

[Jacogos]

Bumping to fix my subscription.

[Craze]

Um, I don't know if you guys are working on it, but the battle between me and Dough still needs to be judged;

http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=38783&p=1245089#post1245089

[SQJ]

It's happening man, don't you worry.

[Craze]

Aight. I wasn't worried though, just curious since it was a little while ago..

[DoughGuy]

Battle Arena (link): http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=35677&page=5&p=1329850&viewfull=1#post1329850
Combatants: Gaara vs Dart Feld
Writers: Jacogos vs. DoughGuy
Post number of first post: 44
Type of battle: Single
Requested judge pair: Anyone

[DoughGuy]

Battle Arena (link):http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=38394&page=7&p=1252838&viewfull=1#post1252838
Combatants: Freya vs Corvo Attano
Writers: Arail vs. DoughGuy
Post number of first post: 63
Type of battle: Single

[Cfavano]

Battle Arena (link): http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=39418
Combatants: Delita Heiral vs, Alanna the lioness
Writers: Cfavano vs Love amore
Post number of first post: 1
Type of battle: single
Requested judge pair: anyone

[SQJ]

dude you sure ur battle is finished?

[Cfavano]

yes. Anna didn't want to continue. She never really like doing it. And she felt bad about having to make me wait and keep asking her to post.

[SQJ]

That's a bit of a problem, I'll get back to you man

[Cfavano]

how is it a problem? there is a precedent. You just award us less points, as there are less posts to judge.

[SQJ]

-draws a blank-
Precedent?

[Cfavano]

Haytham Kenway vs Captain Barbossa.

- - - Updated - - -

It ended in 15 posts.

[SQJ]

That's not exactly the same...I created an exception becase you and Crazy were new and misunderstood the rules so I gave leeway. The actual Rule is Zero points for anything below 90% completion, which is why my Mask battle with Teejail isn't completed or why other battles with other fighters who say they've quit are still listed as running. But generally those are easy fixes since both parties tend to quit. It's also why none of the battles have time lines. You're supposed to have unlimited time to post which is why her concern over wasting your time isn't actually a smut issue. Which means her only valid(to smut) reason to quite the battle is because she's not into fighting you any more. Which puts me into the awkward position of either changing the rule or enforcing the rule and that there is a council issue since I don't like effecting any rules without council support. See where I'm coming from?

[Cfavano]

I don't see why that rule is even there. It seems like it makes everything unnecessarily complex. Like, what if one guy is a dick, and refuses to post anymore, because he knows he's gonna lose. Or, god forbid, someone dies, and therefore can't finish the fight? Does that mean the other players (the one who's not a dick, or dead) have to suffer because of extenuating circumstances? Or, what if a logical closure point has been reached before 30 posts? Does that mean the remaining posts have to be Being just to make the 30 post limit? I think, and this is my opinion, is that 30 posts should be the MAX, and if a fight ends before that, it ends before that. That way, it can be more realistic, and that the players don't have to stretch out a battle that ended at 20 posts, all the way to 30. It just muddles the spirit, and if there are fewer posts to judge, that's less work for the judges.

[SQJ]

Interesting ideas. The council will look over your thoughts.
The game used to be forty posts, thirty posts was a compromise, it's very unlikely it will get lower. BUT if you want to play a lower posting game you can. Its set up so you can

You just get less(/more depending on the battle) points and you have to do more.
There's 3 on 3
Five on five
Tag
Royals
KO
(More to come one day)

All having options of posting less. Unfortunately they either require more battles or more people and the scoring at the end reflects the commitment.

The fact of the matter is, you're not supposed to stretch out a battle, you're supposed to balance out a battle. Figure your characters capabilities out and battle in such a way that your battle spreads out thirty posts. And how well you can use that balancing skill reflects in your Power and Flow in your judging. There's no realism in ending a battle early, unless it's a question of a writer running out of ideas or fading out early(not even fading out early because a winning writer could actually make that work).

Curious though...if someone died in a battle for points, you'd have your hand up asking for points? Some one is dead and your asking for points?

[Cfavano]

no. I'm not saying that. But I'm saying that if that battle ends because of some very unfortunate circumstances, that does not mean it should be simply thrown out, if the players worked really hard on it

[SQJ]

Kk

[DoughGuy]

A battle which goes below 30 posts robs the winner of points since they can't score as high. Also you shouldn't be getting a logical closure before 30 posts because that implies you're creating an ending which, as said in the fighting thread, is not up to the players its up to the judges. If someone is deliberately avoiding a battle then that should be brought up so it can be discussed. Finally in the event if tragic circumstances I would think the battle would be declared null and void.

[Mar]

I saw this conversation, and there should be, like, a time limit. maybe a week?

[DoughGuy]

THis is the wrong place to discuss this, any further posts should b in the OoC thread.

[Cfavano]

Battle Arena (link): http://role-player.net/forum/showthread.php?t=41507
Combatants: Haytham Kenway/Samurai Jack
Writers: Cfavano/Mar
Post number of first post: 1
Type of battle: Single
Requested judge pair: Whoever does it first.

[SQJ]

Noted.

[Cfavano]

yeah, there's no point requesting a specific pair.